After the first three episodes a certain standard has been set for Rings of Power Season 3. It is a high standard, but it is nothing spectacular given the highest budget in television history. Episodes four through six do meet this standard handsomely, and while they do not exceed it exceptionally, they have more than satisfied. We have a set of storylines to follow again, one at a time: Gundabad, Rhûn, Khazad-dûm, and Númenor.

Gundabad / Eryn Galen / Barad-dûr

It is a well known fact that actors are good at acting. This makes it difficult to tell when the characters they play are, in turn, acting. Marnûkh’s “betrayal” was thoroughly convincing and given the fact that I never trusted him, I did believe it was genuine. Otherwise this was a very action-heavy plotline, centred on the infiltration of and escape from Gundabad. 

Arondir

Arondir’s death was not in any way unexpected. Making it at Theo’s hand is a good choice. It’s no secret I have never been a fan of Arondir as a new character, but his death has served a very good purpose: the development of Theo’s character and the vital role of the rebelling Nazgûl. The scenes in episode 6 between Galadriel and Theo are made so much stronger knowing that one of them just so recently murdered the friend of another. Some characters simply serve the story more in death than they do in life. It is my hope that Arondir will continue to be a massive motivation for Theo to reform and fight for the light, as well as for Galadriel to help those she may not have been likely to help before.

The elephant in the room of Arondir’s race does beg to be addressed. The fact of the matter is that there is no evidence anywhere in Tolkien’s works that Eldar can be of other “races” as we view them today. The concept of race as colour is not present in Tolkien’s world with reference to the Eldar, unlike that of Men. There is a great wealth of “cultural diversity” in Middle-Earth when it comes to Men, and inventing things that simply do not exist to satisfy modern-day racial politics in a story we wish to be timeless is disrespectful to the original work. Those who celebrate having non-white Elves do so purely out of a cultural phenomenon, not out of any sense of loyalty to the source material or themes of Tolkien. I argue that such people are being dishonest and doing a disservice to Tolkien’s work and memory. If you think the man was some evil racist, you’re wrong, but that is not my problem. Your job is to adapt his work, not write your own. The same applies to Míriel, a gross miscast in a series that has, thus far, been cast exceptionally well (Vickers, Edwards, and Clark drawing honourable mentions). The Eldar are a pale race, as are the Edain of Númenor. Other peoples, such as the Lossoth, Haradrim, and Easterlings, are not. Cast appropriately.

Galadriel and Celeborn

Other than this, Galadriel and Celeborn’s scenes were among the strongest. The showrunners clearly have done extensive work on understanding their rights, finding words such as Thingol, Doriath, Ancalagon, and Thangorodrim that would not immediately be obvious. While they have forked out for Armenelos and Pallando, they seem to be frugal with their requests. I do hope they are simply saving negotiation capital for things in later seasons, but it could just as easily be a matter of budget. 

Galadriel and Theo also have an interesting dynamic. Her initial reluctance to help him has evolved into a strange willingness to trust and help him. Perhaps she identifies with him as the few who have had personal relationships with Sauron and resisted him. It is easier to face the darkness than to chase what you’ve already lost. And after a while, it’s all you have left of him. Both have lost family to Sauron. Both despise him, and are yet deeply conflicted. I am excited to see where this goes.

Celeborn’s torture, both in Thangorodrim, Angband, Gundabad, and now in Barad-dûr, highlights a very strong theme: resistance against darkness through hope. Tolkien’s theme of Estel is very clear here, always seeing the hope for light. I am reminded of Sam in Mordor seeing a star, and the very thought of such light smiting his soul; my absolute favourite passage in all of Tolkien. One of my favourite scenes thus far is when he tells Galadriel that he survived Thangorodrim with stories of her, finding joy in the deepest, darkest pits of Angband. And if there is joy to be found in Thangorodrim, then outside must be abundant with it. This truly puts his visceral, disgusting torture scene in Barad-dûr into perspective. He has been through worse than bricks. He has been through more physical and psychological torture from Morgoth than any Man could suffer in a lifetime, likely by multiple times. Bricks will not break him.

He can only be broken by love.

Rhûn

Rhûn bothers me to no end and I cannot cease to decry it as the worst idea this show ever had. A Gandalf – Pallando duel that mirrors so closely that with a certain other evil wizard had me wondering if they were going to imprison Gandalf on the roof again. This entire storyline is included for one reason alone, and that is to include an iconic character that has no business being here. It’s full of unnecessary references to Jackson and simply cheapens Saruman’s later betrayal. With no insult meant to Daniel Weyman, who has generally done a very good job filling the shoes of Sir Ian McKellen (a tall task indeed), my eyes simply glaze over whenever I see his character on the screen. My favourite episodes thus far are the ones that don’t involve him. Even after one gets past the sheer amount of timeline illiteracy and breaking directly and explicitly with the source material, he serves zero purpose in the grander story. This is the definition of fan service.

Khazad-dûm

Khazad-dûm has been a strong but uneventful storyline until this point, but we have finally reached the tipping point we’ve all been waiting for. Thráin has revealed his treason and taken the throne, and is searching for the Seven. Durin’s character has grown older and wiser in the five-year break and this shows. He is not the hothead he once was. However, when you have this weakness, there is always the possibility of falling back into it, which his brother manipulates perfectly.

The plot device used to break him has been met with significant controversy. While I do believe this was an opportunity for something slightly more creative, I must defend the choice if only against the onslaught of baseless vitriol the showrunners have been subjected to. Having skeletons in Dísa’s closet does not ruin her character. If anything, it provides an opportunity for Durin to feel great pain as well as forgive. Both characters are able to grow as a result of this coming to light, bringing much-needed flaws and development to Dísa. Those who worship Dísa and are wholly unable to accept that female characters are not always perfect, or that they may die at times, are being unfair to the show, while giving it passes on far more serious faults. I am looking at you, Dr. Sara Brown. The device wasn’t perfect, but it did its job and then some. The plot moves forward, the characters are dimensionalized, and the themes are preserved. When we do not have textual evidence for these events, that’s the only standard I’m really worried about.

Númenor

My final and favourite storyline thus far is that of Númenor. This seems to be a consensus, despite the fact that it is the one most affected by the timeline compression. Míriel and Pharazôn have moved to open war, but far more importantly, Elrond has come to his brother’s home.

Mortality

My other favourite scene from the entire show to this point is the flashback between Elrond and Elros. One of the biggest themes in all of Tolkien (and arguably the single foremost in Second Age Tolkien) is mortality vs immortality, and conflict between Elves and Men. The show’s greatest strength thus far has been including these one-on-one dialogue scenes with deep thematic weight to them. Elros reveals that he chose to be of the Edain rather than the Eldar because of his immense admiration of the race of Men. Elrond is grieved by this: he never expected that his brother would die. Five hundred years is nothing in the reckoning of the Elves, and Elrond lives to be more than six thousand years old before returning to the West. The central exchange of the scene is when Elros asks, “Would you begrudge your brother a journey to the dawn?” To which Elrond responds, “Would you begrudge yours his grief?” This draws upon the distinction between Elves and Men. After a Man’s short life they are granted the Gift of Death, and are restored in spirit to Eru Ilúvatar, the creator beyond the bounds of the world. Elves do not have this privilege, but live on in Middle Earth until either unnatural death or they choose to sail West, where they dwell in the bliss of Valinor: a beautiful but nevertheless imperfect paradise within Arda Marred, a fallen world. Elrond will have no respite from his grief, as his soul will remain in the world until the final day when the world is unmade and remade and he can dwell in a New Arda with his brother. Elros, however, will be given that eternal paradise sooner. He will sail into the dawn figuratively in death, welcomed into the arms of Eru. Elrond will sail into the sunset literally at the end of the Third Age, with the other ring-bearers, carrying his grief. Death, according to the wisest of the Edain, is a small price to pay for what it grants you. Elrond’s later line to Isildur, that he misses his brother’s “trust in the Valar and the power it gave him to let go”, encapsulates how Men must submit to the will of Eru’s appointees in this life, while being joined to the Creator in the next.

Tolkien’s theology deeply influences this, and it becomes even more clear that, at least as far as men are concerned, this is a Christian story at its core. From the burning bush to Celeborn’s sacrifice, we continue to see Christian themes woven into the story which gives me great encouragement. The final test will come when Númenor sinks into the sea and Pharazôn is left alive under mounds of stone, denied the Gift of Men.   

Civil War

In modern-day Númenor, the civil unrest has become a civil war. The armies of Pharazôn have been deployed against those of the Faithful, while Isildur begs Míriel for war. This is a good use of their budget, though unfortunately it is unlikely we will see the two forces unleashed in battle. Elrond’s warning to stay the hand of violence is very powerful as he tries to maintain peace in Númenor. This shows the difference between Isildur, who would avenge his fallen comrades, and Elrond, who understands the bigger picture. I like this comparison as it deepens the disparity between Elves and Men, which will inevitably become the downfall of Númenor. Visuals, writing, and acting here have all been highlights of the show.

I have been hoping since the show’s inception that there would be moments when choice of language or methods of foreshadowing would be written such that those familiar with the source material would be able to smile and nod, knowing what was coming before the general audience understood. I have been disappointed, as most such things are simply references to Jackson with no relationship to the plot whatsoever. As soon as Pharazôn and Míriel were alone in a room, it became very clear what was happening to any who know how this war is resolved. The inclusion of the word “Proposal” would only give a casual fan a slight inkling of what was coming, but it gave the lore enthusiasts a perfect image. This is simply a highly commendable choice of writing. Similarly we have Galadriel being referred to as a Nightingale (a reference to Lúthien Tinúviel in the Silmarillion, though mildly out of place). I wish we would see more of this and less Jackson in this show.

Flaws and Criticisms

Unfortunately not everything made me as happy as it could have. The season continues to be plagued by nonsensical callbacks to Jackson and moments in the Lord of the Rings. To name a few particularly egregious ones: pity staying one’s hand, fighting Nazgûl with a lit torch, Pharazôn eating tomatoes like Denethor, “I did not come here to fight you, but to save you”, and even dragon fire not staining the surface of Fëanor’s hammer. The list grows longer with every episode and it is eliciting more groans than smiles. From a writing standpoint, it would be lovely if the show could be unique in its homage to Tolkien, adapting his work well, rather than an homage to the Peter Jackson film trilogy from the 2000s. 

The other major issue I take here is the origin of the Fell Beasts. While Tolkien did play with this idea, it was rejected. I cannot understand why the show would write dialogue that directly contradicts the words Tolkien wrote; filling in the blanks is not ideal, but it’s acceptable, while this is simply not. What’s more, the actual origin we have in the text is in no way less useful than the one used! Sure, we are not explicitly given the orign story, but let us at least create one that is in line with established lore. These are Morgoth’s feeble imitations of the Eagles, designed to counter them but infinitely lesser in glory and beauty. Why must we literally corrupt all that is good and beautiful in favour of that which is not even true? This change was not only a departure from the lore, but a wholly unnecessary one.

Conclusion

For some summary, these episodes pleased me. Several moments elicited groans and head shakes, but several others, as my family can attest, elicited joyful sounds and furious typing into my notes. The pressure is left to the in-between scenes, the average scenes, the ones that are neither excellent nor terrible, and they held strong this week. I will not say I have no major complaints, because I truly do, but I also have many points of praise. The show has not earned its way out of scepticism, and I await each coming release with apprehension, fearing that it will ruin everything I’ve praised it for thus far. Nevertheless, so far it has not lived up to the fears of how terrible it could be. We will see this time next week how the finale measures up.