The Rings of Power, Season 3, is off to a start that is significantly better than anything I had imagined going in. The two initial episodes are the strongest opening to date, skipping the fluff and going straight to the meat. While they are not without their flaws I am, overall, incredibly happy with the direction the season has started out with. While the show is not out of the woods yet, as the third episode proves, and it is still very easy for this to become the worst season so far if the remainder is poorly done, the first impression has been a definite win. Spoilers ahead.
We have almost entirely cut the eastern plot with the Harfoots and Gandalf for the first two episodes. This subplot was by far the worst and the show is significantly better without it. I could not contain my disappointment when I saw that episode three was almost entirely a Gandalf episode. We are left with four major settings / storylines to follow: Númenor, Rivendell, Khazad-dûm, and Mordor. Each has strengths and weaknesses and I have yet to make a definitive decision regarding my “favourites” yet, but there are no standouts as particularly poorly done, at least in the first two episodes.
Númenor
Our sun today rises in the west: the strongest story thus far is Númenor, by a wide margin. In five years, Pharazôn and the King’s Men have fully seized control of the institutions of the island empire, and the Faithful are now being hung in the public square. While to some degree timeline compression does play into this, the damage was mostly done last season. Eärien’s character became exponentially deeper very quickly as we saw her internal guilt, her true side, and her role as a spy in Pharazôn’s court. Her sudden, shocking, and impossible to predict death was a gut punch. “Maybe it is a gift” was a very strong line, telling the viewer what’s about to happen without giving Pharazôn, Kemen, or Belzagar the slightest clue. While the actual death feels sudden and mildly unearned, I cared about the character enough to be devastated. It’s a real shame that we won’t get more of her going forward. The scene was written, blocked, and shot incredibly well, not to mention acted.
This is not to say, however, that Númenor is without its own issues. This is the story in which Amazon is most hamstrung by their rights: the majority of the best material regarding Númenor is found exclusively in the Akallabêth, the appendix to the Silmarillion. The names of locations (“The Bay of Elros” could easily have been Rómenna) were one point, but there are many many details that the showrunners simply do not have access to. The most significant lore inconsistency here was the Palantír: the seeing-stones do not function as portals to a Wood Between the Worlds where one can physically hug the user of the other stone. However, what they can do is allow you to communicate thoughts, ideas, and feelings, so it isn’t a stretch to say that this is simply the best representation of a wholly mental phenomenon in a visual medium. Even characters speaking to the stone aloud (such as Saruman or Aragorn in the Jackson films) is redundant. Despite these minor and/or legally unavoidable flaws, the Númenor story is getting an A- from me. Which is the best I’ve given to anything so far.
Khazad-Dûm
Khazad-dûm seems the least exciting, as it has the least to do with the outside world and is the most heavily fictional (the dwarves were famously rather united against Sauron and were able to keep him out of the kingdom for the duration of the war), but also has some very strong characters in Durin and Thráin. Disa continues to shine as an incredibly well written character despite having very little in the way of source material. Thráin’s “to trust or not to trust” mini mystery box throughout the first two episodes was relatively well written: one could have guessed if paying close enough attention, but it was not an easy thing to do until he met with the Nazgnagôl. Set design and the visual side of things in Khazad-dûm is appealing and there are no major flaws. The only criticism I have is the meeting between Durin and the emissaries of Mordor. The scene was very clearly set up as a callback to Gimli’s account of Sauron’s emissary in the Third Age, at the Council of Elrond. This obvious reference as well as the direct quotation from the Witch King is honestly unnecessary and does not serve the plot. He could have said anything, and the thing he did say was not at all useful. But other than this once scene, I cannot complain about this story.
Mordor
Mordor is a fascinating plotline. Sauron’s war effort is bearing fruit, but his search for the One Ring is not. He cannot seem to unlock Celebrimbor’s secrets and forge the master ring to dominate the other rings. Overall I like this. The opening scene of him failing to forge it did mildly confuse me, as I was absolutely expecting success at the end of episode four. While this is still possible, the pacing thus far implies that this may come later. Regardless, the primary flaw of this portion is a minor one: all of Sauron’s servants refer to and address the Dark Lord as “Lord Sauron”. Of course, to anyone knowledgeable about the source material this presents an immediate predicament: the Sindarin word “Sauron” means “The Abhorred” and was an insult devised for him by the Sindar of Beleriand. He would never use it or permit it to be used in his presence. Instead, he referred to himself as Tar Maeron, or King Excellent. Perhaps this information is not available: Amazon, of course, lacks the rights to the Silmarillion. Such a minor detail may be overlooked, but it does break a certain sense of immersion.
Theo’s character has been a high point in the otherwise very unimpressive eastern/southern stories. It seems that my initial impulse was correct, and my amended prediction wrong: Theo is to be a Nazgûl, and likely chief among them. Sauron’s manipulation of him is incredibly well written, and every word out of the man’s mouth is dripping with lies, half-truths, and other even more insidious forms of manipulation. While scenes such as the torture of the elvish couple for information regarding Marnûkh showcase his brutal and uncompromising nature, Sauron still has depth as a character: his obsession with Galadriel and his need to avenge himself on her make for a strong secondary motive. One aspect of adaptation is choosing to apply Tolkien’s broad strokes into concrete traits, and this is an aspect the show has done well on: Sauron is described well but briefly. Taking vague traits and turning them into a cohesive character is a hard task well managed.
Rivendell
Rivendell has had relatively little in terms of action. However, the greatest controversy of the season thus far is contained within it. Marnûkh’s “betrayal” is not a very strong plot device, and it introduces some questions regarding believability. After Galadriel’s serious trauma regarding Halbrand’s betrayal, it is hard to imagine her trusting a literal orc as easily as Marnûkh. It requires a significant suspension of disbelief (a concept Tolkien thoroughly rejected). While the overall war effort is quite good, the individual level is much weaker. Galadriel and Arondir’s relationship is poorly written and frankly awkward. This plotline also showcases what is shaping up to be this season’s flaw: callbacks. The entire sequence with Galadriel, Arondir, and Marnûkh is a direct, not even thinly veiled copy and paste of Frodo, Sam, and Gollum’s journey through the Dead Marshes and Cirith Ungol. They may as well have simply reused the script and saved themselves the writing. We even got Orcish poetry, Frodo bidding a wisely distrustful Sam to go home, and “I can’t eat elvish food”. I was almost surprised we weren’t arguing about potatoes or speaking about ourselves in the third person. This is just bad, I’m sorry. Despite containing my favourite character and a significant amount of source material, this is by far the weakest plotline and causes significant dread for Gundabad going forward.
The East
I’d rather not talk about this, but I do suppose we have to deal with Gandalf. The sun is setting in the east here with the worst part of the entire series to date that should have been cut from the beginning. Every second Tom is on the screen I am cringing, so thankfully he’s heading back to see Goldberry and we can avoid worrying about Ben-adar for now. I now fully understand and support Jackson’s decision not to adapt him: it is very difficult to do well, and when done poorly it is very obvious. I also can’t exactly imagine it being done right. Regarding Gandalf himself, the anachronisms are everywhere. If he just arrived, how have both Blue Wizards been here for so long? Where are Saruman and Radagast, and how has nobody noticed them? When does he get his ring from Círdan if he doesn’t arrive in Middle Earth at the Grey Havens? Too many plot holes to count, just to appease the most casual of fans who don’t think it’s a real Lord of the Rings show without Gandalf in it. His scene with the Mûmak was essentially useless, and the Secret Fire was totally unnecessary. While I am very happy to see the Christian imagery of the burning bush, it was handled so clumsily (conflating the Secret Fire with Illúvatar himself) that I’d rather it have been cut entirely. Also, why would the Flame call him names (ie Mithrandir) that he has not yet received? It’s so anachronistic, theologically dubious, and not at all relevant to the story of the Second Age. When I said this has to be a Christian story, I meant thematically, not by shoehorning in a bunch of Jesus Easter eggs and calling it a day. I’m sure anyone could have guessed this but a solid D for Gandalf, and he’s lucky it isn’t an F.
A Note on Flashbacks
To those who want to criticize Galadriel and Celeborn, I do respect you. Most of you. But please leave them be. We’re never going to get Beren and Lúthien in film, and this is a really sweet reference to material that they aren’t allowed to use. Could it have been better? Yes. Could they have used Celeborn’s Teleri name instead and caused a massive scandal? Also yes. Let’s be glad they didn’t. This story is one that Tolkien himself had not settled on, and this creative choice made me, as a First Age enthusiast, very happy. Give them so grace on this count at least.
Conclusion
Despite some criticisms regarding heavy-handed callbacks to Jackson, the Lord of the Rings, and the Old Testament, the first three episodes were of satisfactory quality (the third, by far, the weakest). The first two seasons were plagued by weak middles rescued by strong finales. Hopefully 4-6 will break the cycle and give us cause to celebrate. A further article regarding those three will come out soon after the next drop, followed by one analyzing the finale and a season-wide postmortem later on. For now, my position is one of cautious but increasing optimism. It would still be very easy to screw this up, but in the first three eighths of the season they have not done so. The pacing needs to pick up (which it undoubtedly will), and Marnûkh needs to be wrapped up quickly, but overall, the structure of the plot and the macro-level decisions make me generally happy. I can only hope and pray that the micro-level things will catch up as the season continues.